Wednesday, June 14, 2017

Why (and How) Parents Should Establish a "Zero Tolerance Policy" for Sibling Fighting

After dinner one night I was washing dishes, watching my little kids play in the driveway through the window while my 11-year-old sat on a chair nearby.

She told me about her day while I listened, and after a lull in conversation where the only sound was the water sloshing in the sink she said, "Mom? I guess my brothers and sisters are pretty nice."

"They are," I agreed, putting a plate in the dish drainer. "What makes you say that?"

She told me about a classmate who accidentally wrote her birthday on the wrong day of her school calendar, and when her older brother saw it he took the opportunity to write beside it, "What are you, dumb?"

His message was still there when she came to school today, and my daughter's friend was upset and already plotting her vengeance.

It was hard for my daughter to imagine her siblings doing something like that, and frankly, it was hard for me to imagine, too. Our kids are pretty good friends.

Not to say they always get along perfectly. In fact, two of our six kids currently have their video game privileges suspended for snapping at each other too much lately.

But any fighting between them is usually a one-time reaction to something that just happened. ("You knocked down my tower!" "Stay out of my jewelry box!" "Stop poking me!") It's not part of a pattern of premeditated or unprovoked mean behavior.

I wasn't sure what to say about my daughter's story, so I just said, "Wow, if one of you guys ever did something like that, you'd be in major trouble."

And I think that might be the key.

Sibling fighting can quickly spiral out of control. Written by a mom of 6, here’s how to stop the cycle of sibling rivalry, establish a ‘zero tolerance policy’ for sibling fighting, and other tips for helping sisters and brothers to get along. #siblings #siblingrivalry #improving #parenting #discipline #unremarkablefiles

Just like we sometimes got annoyed with our roommates in college because they made too much noise, used our stuff, created a mess, and invaded our personal space, siblings also get annoyed with each other. And being human, sometimes they lose their temper and react badly.

But how parents handle those reactions matter.

If we allow our kids to talk to each other in a way we wouldn't stand by and listen to them talk to a friend, or treat them in a way that would upset us to find they'd been treating another kid at school, something is wrong.

Every time there's meanness between siblings, we as parents have a choice: we can roll our eyes and accept it as normal behavior, or we can stop both kids and let them know it's not okay.

By tolerating a few rude names or sneaky pushes, we're allowing things to snowball into what we call sibling rivalry. Kids quickly get trapped in a cycle where each of them is constantly seeking revenge (yes, I've heard kids use that word) against the other.

If we allow our kids to treat each other in a way that would upset us to find they'd been treating another kid at school, something is wrong.  {posted @ Unremarkable Files}

So what do you do if your kids are already trapped in the sibling rivalry cycle, teasing each other until someone cries and telling their friends at school how much they hate each other?

I believe you can sit down and talk about what you've been seeing. Explain that effective as of right now, this family has a new "zero tolerance" policy. Every single time, for every act of meanness, there will be consequences. Then follow through.

Easier said than done, I know. Being consistent is the hardest thing there is when you're an exhausted parent. But I promise it will be worth it.

Some other tips to escape from the cycle of sibling rivalry:
  • Give them opportunities to have fun together, like going to a movie or out for ice cream
  • Create goals to work toward together, like cumulatively earning points toward a reward
  • Consider "punishing" them for being mean by requiring them to think of and do something nice for their sibling
  • Catch them being nice to each other and praise them, especially in front of others
  • When you must discipline, say something like "you're such a nice person, please try to be kind to your brother" instead of "you're always so mean to him!"
Do siblings always have to agree, get along, and want to spend time together? Of course not.

But even when they're sick to death of each other and need time apart, expect civility. We should never demand that kids treat their own family with less respect than everyone else around them.

Click to Share:
Unremarkable Files


Anonymous said...

Thanks for these helpful tips! I love your blog.

Ann-Marie Ulczynski said...

This is great. We currently have the 'sweet sister chart' hanging up. Anytime I catch them doing something kind and helpful for their sister, I write it on the chart. When the chart is full, they get a prize. In this case new, desperately needed water bottles (but they don't need to know that). Catching the good helps to curtail the bad. We also point out that God put them in this family, with these siblings for a good reason. Maybe that sibling is the one who will help you develop kindness, generosity, patience, etc.

PurpleSlob said...

Oh Jenny, I love this!! currently working on this with almost 4 yo, and 14 mo. They do love each other, and sometimes hug, and snuggle. So precious! then- other times! but I always stop them! And say "Hey- you love each other!! Don't hurt Sissy!"

Lyndsay said...

I needed to read this. My kids have spiraled into a cycle of arguing recently, and I hate to admit that I have struggled at how to deal with it at times. It also happened exactly as you described. A couple of times I was busy or preoccupied and I let their picking at each other go it has become a bit of a problem. It is probably not even a normal amount of arguing for most families, but it is out of hand for our family.
Thank you for writing this article!

Jenny Evans said...

It doesn't take long AT ALL for this to happen... every now and then we'll have to put our foot (back) down and say "enough is enough" and get tough on bickering behavior because it's crept in while we weren't paying attention. Good luck!

Lindsay said...

I love the book "Siblings without Rivalry" by Adelee Farber and Elaine Mazlish. The thing I love most is that they give you tools to stop it if you already have the fighting. And there is illustrations!!